Mass v. Brown
Mass v. Brown
Opinion of the Court
Opinion of the Court, delivered by
Mass sued Brown before a justice of the • peace, and obtained a judgment: from this judgment, Brown appealed to the circuit court; and that court deciding in favor of Brown, Mass appealed to this court.
On the trial of the cause in tjie circuit court, the appellant, Mass, gave iu evidence a promissory note, made to
On (his evidence, the circuit court decided against the ° claim of Mass, on the note for $100, and gave judgment ^or defendant, Brown.
It seems to me very plain, that when Mass instituted his first suit agaipst Brown, on the two notes'for $100, and for $^0, ^at ^ie just*ce no authority to make two cases of the one action; and consequently that his judgment against the plaintiff, Mass, on the note for $100, was entirely void, ancj that the transcript of such judgment, ought not to have . . f ' ° ° . . been received m evidence by the circuit court. 'I he plam-Mass, could not appeal from a judgment on half of his demands; and Brown must not be permitted to profit by Eis own- wrongful act, and the blunder of the j ustice.
The judgment of the circuit courtis, therefore, reversed, and the cause will be remanded to the circuit court, to be proceeded in agreeably to this opinion.
As the Transcript offered in evidence, showed that no final disposition had been made of the cause, and for ought that appeared, the cause was still pending, the record was improperly admitted in evidence.. W. SCOTT.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Joseph Mass v. Moses Brown
- Status
- Published