Supreme Court of Missouri, 1912

State ex rel. Casualty Co. of America v. Muench

State ex rel. Casualty Co. of America v. Muench
Supreme Court of Missouri · Decided January 27, 1912 · Graves, Latter, Valliant, Who, Woodson
239 Mo. 191; 143 S.W. 500; 1912 Mo. LEXIS 74

State ex rel. Casualty Co. of America v. Muench

Opinion of the Court

WOODSON, J.

— By stipulation of parties, this case was submitted with the case of. State ex rel. Pacific Mutual Life. Insurance Company v. Grimm, decided by this court, In Banc, at the present term, and reported at page 135.

There is no difference between the substantial .facts of the two cases; and having reached the conclusion in that case that the peremptory writ of prohibition prayed for should be denied, and that the preliminary rule heretofore issued should be quashed, we, are, therefore, of the opinion that a similar judgment should be rendered in this case. It is so ordered.

All concur except Valliant, G. J., and Graves, J., who dissent in a separate opinion by the latter.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.