Wilson v. Owens
Wilson v. Owens
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The record in this case does not show that the exceptions to the opinions of the court were taken at the time, and before the jury retired from the box. Repeated decisions of the supreme court of
It is the question arising upon the motion of the plaintiff, to enter a nonsuit in the court below, after verdict found. The jury had returned a verdict for the defendant for twelve dollars and fifty cents; and the motion of the plaintiff in error was predicated upon the 18th section of the circuit court law; which provides, that if any suit shall be commenced in any circuit court, for a less sum than such court can legally take cognizance of; or if any person shall demand a greater sum than is due on purpose to evade this act, in either case the plaintiff shall be nonsuited and pay costs, provided, &e.
In this case there is nothing to show that suit was commenced for more than was due; or that the defendant demanded in his writ a greater sum than was due on purpose to evade the law defining the jurisdiction of the circuit court; and one of these two cases must be shown to exist to the satisfaction of the circuit court, before it would be competent for such court to non-suit the plaintiff. Presuming that there was no greater evidence of such fact produced to the court below than the record shows, I am convinced that the overruling of the motion was correct.
.Tudgment will therefore be affirmed.
Reference
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published