Berthe v. Biggs
Berthe v. Biggs
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The defendant below demurred, and assigned causes—
1. A variance between the writing declared on and that given on oyer.
2. That the contract created no individual liability, the estate of Ellis only being liable.
3. That the endorsement on the instrument showed the estate of Ellis.to be in the hands of Blanton, the trustee.
There is no ground for the first cause of demurrer. The declaration does not describe the consideration, the use for which it was intended, or the liability of the estate, as expressed in the writing obligatory; but this cannot make a variance, as it would have been surplusage, the description of the obligation being complete without a reference to the purpose for which it was incurred.
The second cause of demurrer is equally groundless. The liability created was personal: although it may have been created
The judgment must be affirmed.
Reference
- Status
- Published