Barnes v. Jarnagin
Barnes v. Jarnagin
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is an action of assumpsit instituted against James H. Mosely, executor, and Sarah Barnes, executrix, founded upon an open account contracted by the testator of the defendants in the circuit court. Service of process was had upon the executrix only, and she failing to appear and plead, the action was thereupon discontinued as to the executor, and a judgment as by default and a writ of inquiry, with a finding and judgment thereon, were entered against the executrix.
This case fully presents to us the question, whether to warrant a judgment against the estate of deceased persons, represented by two or more executors or administrators, there must not be service against all of those representatives. This point as yet has not been fully determined in this court, although it has been incidentally remarked upon in the case of Breckenridge's Adm’r. v. Mellon’s Adm’r., 1 How. 273, and in that of Woodward, Judge, &c., use, &c., v. Brown’s Adm’r., 11 S. & M. 303. We have held, that in order to render a judgment against partners valid, there must be service upon or appearance by all the partners. This is because the judgment is binding upon them jointly, and severally, upon the partnership fund and their individual property. It is true that executors or administrators fill but one office, that the act of one is the act of all, and that a judgment against them is binding only upon the estate, but the object of this representation of an estate is for its benefit. The law permits more-than one executor or administrator to be intrusted with the settlement of an estate. This rule may have been adopted from the complexity of the business of some estates, or from the fact that more than one
In the present case, the judgment -was erroneously taken against but one of the representatives, and it was erroneous to have discontinued the cause as to the executor not served with process.
Judgment reversed, and cause remanded for further proceedings. »
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Sarah Barnes, of John Barnes v. H. L. Jarnagin
- Status
- Published