Board of Supervisors v. City of Brookhaven
Board of Supervisors v. City of Brookhaven
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The city of Brookhaven brought suit against the board of supervisors of Lawrence county to recover $689.91, being on account of the pauper taxes assessed by the board for the year 1869, and which had been paid to the tax collector by the inhabitants of said city. The plaintiff claims that, because of special legislation, growing out of the formation and organization of Lincoln county, in part of the territory of Lawrence county, Brookhaven should recover back this money. The grounds taken by the counsel for the appellants, for the reversal of the judgment, does not require an investigation of the merits of the claim against the county of Lawrence; and since the appellee is not represented by counsel in this court, we are not disposed to consider any other questions than those specifically made by the plaintiff in error. On overruling the motion for a new trial, the whole case, as presented to the jury, was embodied in the bill of exceptions. The board of supervisors had by plea made the defense that the city of Brookhaven had not presented its demands as a creditor to the board of supervisors for allowance, nor was there evidence on the trial that the claim had ever been preferred before the board to be audited and allowed. Was that an element in the plaintiff’s right of action in the circuit court? Sec. 1381, Code 1871, enacts that “ all demands and accounts against the county shall be audited and allowed on due proof in term time,” and a warrant shall be issued on the county treasurer. This implies that the board shall scrutinize “demands and accounts.” But the decision of the board, if adverse to the creditor, shall not be conclusive against him. He may, under § 1383, appeal to the circuit court, embodying the facts and evidence in a bill of exceptions, or under § 1381, he may bring suit in the circuit court. This section does not intend that the circuit court
It follows, that the .plaintiff must aver and prove the special facts which entitle him to sue in the circuit court. The demurrer to the plea ought to have been applied to the first material defect in the pleading. The declaration is faulty in omitting to aver that the claim was presented to the board of supervisors and rejected. The law imperatively requires the board to audit and allow all just claims; and it must be presumed, if the demand of the plaintiff was of that character, the board would have allowed it if it had been presented. No testimony was offered on the trial that the claim had ever been before the board for allowance.
Judgment reversed, and judgment in this court, applying and sustaining the demurrer to the declaration and cause, remanded for further proceedings.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Board of Supervisors of Lawrence County v. City of Brookhaven
- Cited By
- 11 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Claims Against a County : How and when they may he sued on. 1. A party holding a claim against any county may present his claim to the board of supervisors for allowance. If they refuse to allow it, he may bring suit against the county in any court of competent jurisdiction. Code, 1871, § 1384. 2. Or he may appeal to the circuit court directly from the order of the board rejecting or disallowing his claim, embodying the facts and evidence in a bill of exceptions. Code, 1871, § 1383. 3. A creditor of a county has no access to the circuit court to have his rights adjudicated, until after his claim has been rejected by the board of supervisors. 4. The statute does not intend that the county shall be unnecessarily vexed with suits and costs, and declares that every person who has a claim against a county must first submit it to the investigation and decision of the board, and must pass through the board before he can obtain a standing in the circuit court as appellant or as plaintiff in an original suit. And in a suit against the county, the fact that the claim was presented to, and disallowed by, the board must be averred in the declaration.