Allen v. Standifer
Allen v. Standifer
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The refusal of the court to permit the plaintiff to file a statement of the claim, when the motion was made by the defendants for judgment, because the plaintiff had failed to file a written statement of his claim, was based on the language of the ninth section of “ An Act to provide for Agricultural Liens and for other purposes,” approved April 14,1876 (Acts 1876, p. 109), under which this proceeding was had. That language is, “ That on or before the return day of such writ in the Circuit Court, the plaintiff shall file with the papers in such cause a statement setting forth in full his claim, and the defendant or defendants making any defence or claim shall in like manner file a- statement of his or their defence or claim, when such suit shall be considered at issue.” . The next section directs that the court “ shall allow all amendments of the proceedings necessary to a full development and settlement of the rights of the different parties.”
This was clearly erroneous. It was following the letter, in disregard of the spirit of the statute, and in forgetfulness of the important truth that “ the letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life.” The spirit of modern and enlightened jurisprudence is to administer justice. Regard is had for matters of substance rather than form in judicial proceedings. Courts are now regarded as existing for the enforcement of rights and the redress of wrongs, and not as places for the exhibition of professional cunning and judicial smartness in discerning finely drawn distinctions between the proper commencement and conclusion of pleadings, and cases of express and implied color, and special traverses and the like subtleties, which in the past constituted so large a part of the boasted common law.
The amendment should have been allowed. It would have done no harm. It operated no surprise to the defendants. Théy had responded to the affidavit of the plaintiff and concluded to the country, thus treating the issue as formed. A statement of the plaintiff’s claim was necessary,because required
Judgment reversed and cause remanded.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- R. H. Allen v. N. E. Standifer
- Status
- Published