Mississippi Supreme Court, 1889

Georgia Pacific Railway Co. v. West

Georgia Pacific Railway Co. v. West
Mississippi Supreme Court · Decided April 15, 1889 · Campbell
66 Miss. 310; 6 So. 207

Georgia Pacific Railway Co. v. West

Opinion of the Court

Campbell, J.,

delivered the opinion of the court.

After carefully examining the evidence in this case and the instructions as applicable to it, we do not think that they are subject to the objections urged by counsel.

It may be admitted that some of the instructions for the plaintiff are not expressed with verbal accuracy in all respects, and that some of the language of the court in modifying several instructions asked by the defendant is not felicitous, but the substantial meaning of the instructions is plain, and the jury could not have been misled by them, and in such case their verdict should not be disturbed, if there is sufficient evidence to sustain it, as in this case.

We are not disposed to regard the objection to the instructions on the ground of want of applicability to the issue made by the pleadings, since, if that had been urged in the court below, when the instructions were presented, and found valid, an immediate amendment should have been ordered. Affirmed.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.