Wilkes v. Gates
Mississippi Supreme Court
Wilkes v. Gates, 68 Miss. 263 (Miss. 1890)
Campbell
Wilkes v. Gates
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
Conceding the right of Wilkes, as substituted trustee, he failed to maintain the action by evidence. Its full import is that the horse sued for was embraced in the deed of trust executed by Posey, and that the debt it was given to secure was still unpaid, all of which being true, shows no right to the horse taken by the writ from Gates, who is not shown to have acquired the horse from Posey or any one claiming under him; nor does it appear that his claim arose subsequently to the execution of the deed of trust. Por all that appears, Gates may have been the owner and possessor of the horse' prior to, and at the time of the execution of the deed of trust.
Affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Henry Wilkes v. Willis Gates
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Replevin. Right to recover. Sufficiency of evidence. In replevin by the trustee in a trust-deed to recover possession of a horse from one not the grantor, and who does not claim under him, plaintiff’s evidence is insufficient if it merely identifies the horse as the one embraced in the trust-deed, but fails to show ownership in the grantor when the instrument was executed.