Conklin v. Alabama & Vicksburg Railway Co.

Mississippi Supreme Court
Conklin v. Alabama & Vicksburg Railway Co., 81 Miss. 152 (Miss. 1902)
Calhoon

Conklin v. Alabama & Vicksburg Railway Co.

Opinion of the Court

Calhoon, J.,

delivered the opinion of the court.

The heir could not, nor could the executor or administrator, under the common law, sue at law for damages done by trespass committed during the lifetime of the ancestor on the lands of the ancestor. Broom, Leg. Max., top page 911; Plowd., 142; 2 Saund. Pl. & Ev., 868; 2 Mod., 7; 1 Saund., 216, note 217, *162note; Barb. Parties, 176; Wilbur v. Gilmore, 21 Pick., 252; Reed v. Railroad Co., 18 Ill., 403. This, being the common law, is still the law, unless changed by statute. It has not, so far as concerns the heir, been changed in this state. Sections 1916, 1917, code 1892, simply give the right to sue to the executor or administrator. They do not give it to the heir. Hence he cannot sue. The case of Marshall v. King, 24 Miss., 85, decides that the distributee cannot recover at law. Equity courts may be invoked in certain states of case, but chancery powers, remedial and protective, are large โ€” such as the requirement of bonds to indemnify, and to restore property to save harmless such persons as premature distribution might injure. Law courts cannot do this. The crucial test in the case before us is that, if recovery were had and the damages paid, and debts of the intestate did develop, the administrator could recover again.

Affirmed.

Reference

Full Case Name
Andrew J. Conklin v. Alabama & Vicksburg Railway Company
Cited By
5 cases
Status
Published
Syllabus
1. Trespass to Lands. Death of owner. Survival of actions. Parties. Heirs. The heirs of a decedent cannot recover at law for a trespass to the lands of their ancestor committed in his lifetime, although there is no administration upon or debt due by the estate of the decedent. 2. Same. Code 1892, ยง? 1916, 1917. Executors and administrators. Code 1892, 1916, 1917, providing for the survival of causes of action, give the right to sue for trespass to lands, upon the death of the owner, to his executor or administrator and not to his heirs.