Stark v. State
Stark v. State
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The indictment was drawn under code, § 1218, against the exposure of the person in a public place, etc. The statute requires the exhibition to be “willfully and lewdly” made. Thé indictment charges that it was ‘£ unlawfully and willfully ’ ’ made, omitting the word £ £ lewdly. ’ ’ If this may be left out, so may the wore) £ £ willfully, ” by the same process of reasoning, leaving the whole charge to depend on the word £ £ unlawfully.” We hold, therefore, that the indictment is void on its face. The statute does not use the word £ £ unlawfully. ’ ’ The pleader very properly did, but he failed to use a word essential to the description of the offense, so as to support the pleader’s conclusion that the act was unlawful. Cook v. State, 72 Miss., 517 (17 South., 228); Dee v. Same, 68 Miss., 601 (9 South., 356); Lewis v. Same, 49 Miss., 354; Harrington v. Same, 54 Miss., 490; Roberts v. Same, 55 Miss., 421; and the other cases cited in Brame & A. Dig., p. 305, secs. 93-99, and those in George’s Dig., p. 814, secs. 305-312. The exposure may be willful, because sometimes inescapably necessary, and yet not at all lewd ; and this is of the very essence of the offense,
Even if defendant had been properly indicted and convicted under' proper instruction, the statute limits the judgment of imprisonment to twenty days, and the court was without power to sentence him for thirty days, as it did.
Reversed and remanded.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- James Stark v. State of Mississippi
- Cited By
- 7 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- 1. Criminal Law. Exposure of person. Code 1893, § 1318. An indictment, under code 1893, § 1318, making it a misdemeanor to willfully and lewdly expose the person, or the private parts thereof, in any public place, etc., is fatally defective if it fail to charge that the exposure was lewdly made. 3. Same. Instruction. An instruction in such a case directing the jury to convict defendant if they believe he did a specified act in a public place is erroneous if it omit the idea that to constitute the crime the act must have been done unlawfully, willfully and lewdly. 3. Same. Punishment. The statute prescribes the punishment for its violation, and a greater punishment cannot be imposed.