Weatherbee v. Lillybeck

Mississippi Supreme Court
Weatherbee v. Lillybeck, 86 Miss. 156 (Miss. 1905)
Whiteield

Weatherbee v. Lillybeck

Opinion of the Court

Whiteield, C. J.,

delivered the opinion of the court.

The case of Allen v. Caffee, recently decided, controls this case in its essential features. See that case, 85 Miss., 766 (s.c., 38 South. Rep., 186). There is one other matter to be noted. Weatherbee is not entitled to any credit for the $150 paid for the articles which he bought of Suttle & Mars, which articles were the private property of Suttle & Mars, and did not belong to the house. Weatherbee owns the articles, and they seem to have been worth money. Weatherbee Bros, cannot “eat their cake and keep it too.” The action of the court in this regard was correct. But appellants are entitled to set off against the plaintiff’s demand all legal damages actually sustained by them in getting possession of the property, in 'accordance with the principles laid down in Allen v. Coffee, supra.

Reversed and remanded.

Reference

Full Case Name
Walter C. Weatherbee v. Oscar Lillybeck
Status
Published
Syllabus
Warranty Deed. SvAt for purchase money. Recoupment. In a suit by a grantor for the purchase money of land conveyed by general warranty the grantee: O) May recoup damages sustained by reason of expenses incurred by him in getting possession of the land; but (6) Is not entitled to credit for the costs of store fixtures purchased by him from the occupant to induce a surrender of the premises.