Edwards v. Butler
Edwards v. Butler
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The land in this case was granted to the state of Mississippi by Act Congress July 4, 1836 (5 Stat., 116, ch. 355), and Act Congress June 13, 1842 (5 Stat., 490, ch. 39), in lieu of six
The act of 1888,'“an act to quiet and settle the title to certain lands in the Yazoo delta which were sold by the commissioners of the chancery court of Hinds county,” etc. (Laws 1888, p. é0, ch. 23), as a matter of course was never intended to embrace any other lands than the character of lands set out in the caption of that act, and had no relation whatever to lands like those in this record. The history of the act of 1888 is perfectly well known. It was intended, as it states, to quiet the title to certain lands in the Yazoo delta, which had been sold by the commissioners of the chancery court of Hinds county. The title to these lands had become involved in the greatest possible confusion by reason of numerous tax sales occurring at various times, and this confusion constituted so great a cloud upon the title to lands in that delta that this act, wisely or unwisely, was passed to* quiet title to that specific character of lands. The legislature never dreamed of applying its provisions to any other lands than those named in the caption of the act, and hence the land in controversy was totally unaffected, of course, by its provisions. To give the act the opposite construction would make' it manifestly unconstitutional.
The decree is reversed, and the cause remanded, to be proceeded with in accordance with this opinion.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- George R. Edwards v. George W. Butler
- Cited By
- 3 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- 1. Taxation. Chickasaw school lands. Acts of Congress, 5 Stat. at Large 116, ch. 355; II). 490, ch. 39. Lands granted to the state by congress “for the use and benefit of schools,” known as the “Chickasaw school lands,” were not taxable while title remained in the state, and a sale for taxes of nontaxable land is void. 2. Same. Auditor’s deed. An auditor’s deed, predicated of a tax sale, will not invest the grantee therein with title to Chickasaw school land improperly sold to the state for taxes before it became the subject of private ownership. 3. Same. Laws 1888, ch. 23, p. 40. Quieting tax titles. Laws 1888, ch. 23, p. 40, entitled “An act to quiet and settle the title to certain lands in Yazoo Delta which were sold by the commissioners of the chancery court of Hinds county,” etc., embraced no other lands than those mentioned in the caption of the aett and had no relation to Chickasaw school lands which had been illegally sold by the state for taxes.