Greenburg v. Massey
Greenburg v. Massey
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The statute (§ 2401, Ann. Code 1892) requires a written statement of the cause of action. The widest liberality that can be indulged as to pleadings in the courts of justices of the peace cannot cover a total failure to file any written statement of the cause of action whatever. The true rule is that there must be such a written statement of the cause of action as can be successfully pleaded by the defendant, if sued again on the same cause of action — such a statement as will give the defendant the benefit of a plea of res judicata. This is clearly shown by the ease of Butts v. Phelps, 79 Mo., 302.
The judgment is reversed, and the cause remanded, with leave to amend.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Henry Greenburg v. William Massey
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Justice of the Peace. Pleadings. Statement of cause of action. Code 1892, § 2401. The filing of an affidavit simply charging that defendant is justly indebted to plaintiff in a designated sum does not comply with Code 1892, § 2401, requiring any one desiring to sue before a justice of the peace to lodge with him “the evidence of debt, statement of account or other written statement of the cause of action” of which the suit is predicated.