Batson v. Thompson Land & Lumber Co.
Batson v. Thompson Land & Lumber Co.
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The only question for determination in this case is whether or not there was error in the action of the court below in giving a peremptory instruction to- the jury to find for the defendant in the court below.
The Thompson Land & Lumber Company was a partnership,, and not a corporation. It had been conducting a sawmill business, but in February, 1905, sold its plant, certain lands, timber-racks, and its personal property to a man by the name of Strong, who in March, 1905, conveyed all the same property to a corporation called the Magnolia Milling Company. It seems that E. L. Thompson was the manager under the partnership, and continued to have such relation with the vendees of .the plant. In August, 1905, Batson was the owner of some logs, which he testifies he sold to Thompson, without any knowledge of any transfer of interest, and thinking he Avas selling to the Thompson Land & Lumber Company. The account not being paid at maturity, he sued the original partnership in the court of a justice of the. peace, and recovered a personal judgment against E. L. Thompson. Whether or not there Avas any sale in fact is controverted, and there is testimony on both sides. Whether or not Batson had any knowledge of the transfer of the plant when he ipade the sale to- Thompson, if he did make any sale,, is controverted.
In support of the proposition on the part of Thompson Land & Lumber Company that there was notice to Batson of the conveyance of the plant, the deed of conveyance is produced, and
We think, on the whole case, the facts should have been left to the jury for determination, and that the peremptory instruction against the plaintiff was error.
Reversed! and remanded.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.