Yazoo & Mississippi Valley Railroad v. McGraw
Yazoo & Mississippi Valley Railroad v. McGraw
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
Appellees brougth suit to recover fourteen dollars and ninety-nine cents actual damages and sixty-five dollars delayage charges under rule 10 of the Mississippi State Railroad Commission, claimed by reason of the delay in the transmission by appellant of one car of staves, shipped from Anding, Mississippi, to New Orleans, Louisiana. The case was tried before the court, a jury being waived, upon an agreed statement of facts.
On the trial, appellees were required to elect whether they would claim actual damages or for delayage charges, and they elected to claim the delayage charges. -Judgment was rendered by the court in favor of appellees-for the sum of sixty-five dollars, the amount of delayage charges.
The part of rule 10 of the Mississippi Bailroad Commission applicable in this case reads as follows: ‘ ‘Where cars are detained in transit by being switched to some track between point of shipment and destination, one dollar per ear will be charged for each day, or fraction of a day, of delay thus caused, and no free time will in such case be “allowed.”
Counsel for appellant make the following statement of one of their reasons for contending that the trial court
We believe that counsel for appellant are correct in their contention. We do not see that tbe Mississippi Railroad Commission can by its rules control or regulate tbe handling or transmission of cars after they pass outside tbe limits of tbe state. Tbe territory over which tbe Commission has jurisdiction in its demurrage and delay-age rules is confined to tbe state of Mississippi. The court erred in rendering judgment against appellant for tbe delayage charges.
We note that appellees were put upon their election as to which claim they should assert on tbe trial of tbe cause, and that they have bad no trial of their claim for actual damages.
Reversed and remanded.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Yazoo & Mississippi Valley Railroad Company v. H. T. & W. McGraw
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Railkoad Commission. Rules. Interstate shipments. Delay.age. Rule 10 of the Mississippi Railroad Commission, providing that where cars are detained in transit by being switched to some track between point of shipment, and destination, one dollar per car will be charged for each day, or fraction of a day, of delay thus caused,” does not apply to interstate shipments from a point within this state where the delay was at a point outside this state.