Mississippi Supreme Court, 1925

Dunbar-Du-Kate Co. v. Harper

Dunbar-Du-Kate Co. v. Harper
Mississippi Supreme Court · Decided November 23, 1925 · Smith
106 So. 5; 140 Miss. 439; 1925 Miss. LEXIS 277 (Southern Reporter)

Dunbar-Du-Kate Co. v. Harper

Opinion of the Court

*442 Smith, C. J.,

delivered the opinion of the court.

The responsibility for the appellee’s injury must be referred to his own negligence in attempting to turn his wagon around on a bridge, the space therefor being so limited as to render it practically impossible for him to do so with safety.

Conceding that the appellant was charged with the duty of maintaining a suitable railing along the side of the bridge, it was not required to maintain such a railing as would withstand the extraordinary strain placed on it by the appellee’s negligence. The peremptory instruction requested by the appellant should have been granted.

Reversed, and judgment here for appellant.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.