Union Oil Co. v. McLaughlin
Union Oil Co. v. McLaughlin
Opinion of the Court
Appellee, McLaughlin, sued the appellant Company in the Circuit Court of Wayne County alleging damages to the surface of approximately fifteen acres of land on which the Company drilled a dry hole pursuant to a lease held by it. Judgment was entered for $1,000 in favor of McLaughlin.
The evidence is sufficient to carry the issue of liability to the jury. We do not deem it necessary to set out such evidence.
The judgment for $1,000, however, in our opinion, is not justified by the evidence and is so excessive as to evidence bias and prejudice on the part of the jury. If the appellee, within fifteen days from the date
Affirmed on condition of $500 remittitur ; otherwise reversed and remanded for a new trial on damages alone.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- UNION OIL COMPANY OF CALIFORNIA v. Joe McLAUGHLIN
- Status
- Published