Montana Supreme Court, 1818

Goodrich v. Pendleton

Goodrich v. Pendleton
Montana Supreme Court · Decided October 6, 1818
3 Johns. Ch. 520; 1818 N.Y. LEXIS 216; 1818 N.Y. Misc. LEXIS 44
Goodrich v. Pendleton

Opinion of the Court

The Chancellor.

Both of the objections are well taken. The plaintiff, who sues ,® autre droit, is not responsible for costs, if he fails, except under special circumstances ; and he ought not to be obliged to enter into personal security, in the first instance. The defendant has, moreover, waived his right to such security by his plea. The rule is, that if the non-residence of the plaintiff appears, on the bill, the defendant waives his title to security for costs, if he takes any step in the cause, or even prays time to answer. (2 Vesey, 24. 10 Vesey, jun. 287.) In Long v. Tardy, (1 Johns. Ch. Rep. 202.) a demurrer by the defendant was held to be a waiver.

Motion denied.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.