Kleinschmidt v. Kleinschmidt
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Baan v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1965)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
On December 3, 1886, Albert Kleinschmidt transferred absolutely to John W. Buskett one-eighth of his (Kleinsehmidt’s) interest in the profits arising from the construction of the Helena, Boulder Valley and Butte Railroad. This was for a consideration delivered by Buskett, and received by Kleinschmidt. The transaction was evidenced by a writing signed by Kleinschmidt, and delivered to Buskett. Defendant proved that the loan of $1,350 was on January 5, 1887, and that for this loan Buskett gave him a promissory note, at ninety days, which had been renewed by Buskett, and negotiated by Kleinschmidt, in 1887. The court refused to allow defendant to prove whether the debt had been paid. Now, in this condition of affairs, on April 22, 1887, T. H. Kleinschmidt, plaintiff, buys from Buskett, for a valuable consideration, his one-eighth interest. Afterwards, and on October 22, 1888, the money for Buskett’s one-eighth interest’ in the contract comes into the hands of Albert Kleinschmidt, along with Kleinsclimidt’s own profits, which he had not transferred. ’ Now T. H. Kleinschmidt is in court demanding from Albert Kleinschmidt that he (Albert Kleinschmidt) deliver to him that which he (T. H. Kleinschmidt) bought from Buskett. Albert Kleinschmidt declines to deliver these profits to T. H. Kleinschmidt, and says that he holds them as security for the payment of said $1,350, and interest at twelve per cent per annum since January 5, 1887. The position of Albert Kleinschmidt seems to be that he claims that these alleged facts are an absolute defense to the action of plaintiff. But whether a defense or a counterclaim or a setoff, it does not here seem necessary to determine, as will appear below.
The writing of December 3, 1886, by which Albert Kleinschmidt and Henry Klein transferred the one-eighth interest in the profits to John W. Buskett, was not a negotiable instrument. Therefore, when Buskett transferred his interest so obtained in these profits to T. H. Kleinschmidt the latter took the same subject to the provisions of section 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which is as follows: “In the case of an assignment of a thing in action, the action by the assignee shall be
Respondent urges some other points upon which he contends that his judgment should be sustained, notwithstanding the error above discussed. But those matters which he presents
Reversed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.