Gaddy v. Kern
Cases that cite this one
28 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Weavil v. Summer Industries (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2011)
- Barbour v. Sawyer's Land Developing (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2009)
- King v. Capital of Cary (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2011)
- Kyazimova v. South. Heart and Vascular Center (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2011)
- Reid v. Hospira, Inc. (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2010)
- Evans v. Stellar Management Group (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2010)
- Wooten v. Dillard's, Inc. (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2009)
- Kornegay v. Cooper Tire Rubber Co. (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2008)
- Thompson v. Kroger Company (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2008)
- Forrest v. Oem America (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2007)
- Tarkington v. Pearidge Convenience Store (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2011)
- Ayers v. Mountain River Trucking Company (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2009)
- Ayers v. Mountain River Trucking Co. (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2009)
- Harwood v. Modern Tower Solutions (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2011)
- McGriff v. Janiyah Shoe Forum (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2010)
- Carney v. Greenville Tv Appliance, Inc. (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2010)
- Steen v. Triad International Maintenance Corp. (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2010)
- Blakeney v. Blythe Cons. (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2010)
- Barber v. Air Specialties of Pinehurst, Inc (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2010)
- Townes v. Britthaven, Inc. (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2009)
- Shipman v. Jessup Auto Sales, Inc. (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2007)
- Charity v. Davis Resource Management, Inc. (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2006)
- Brizell v. Kroger (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2006)
- Powers v. Craven Regional Medical Center (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2006)
- Charles v. Ihop (North Carolina Industrial Commission 2003)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Plaintiff has argued that the Industrial Commission erred in not considering his evidence concerning severe headaches which he began to experience some three months after the injury occurred. It is his contention that the headaches are evidence of a general disability for which he is entitled to compensation under G.S. 97-30, and that the headache evidence necessitates a finding of a greater disability than that of 20% in his left hand.
Where the claimant has suffered injury as a result of accident arising out of and in the course of his employment of a specific nature included in G.S. 97-31, compensation provided by 97-31 for such specific injury is granted in lieu of all other compensation, except that he may also be entitled to compensation under G.S. 97-29 for total temporary disability
Here the plaintiff received compensation during the healing period of the hand injury under G.S. 97-29, and after the healing period from the point of maximum recovery, for partial loss of use of his hand under G.S. 97-31(12).
But plaintiff also contends that the headaches entitled him to compensation under G.S. 97-30, which authorizes compensation for partial incapacity for work resulting from injury, not otherwise covered by G.S. 97-31.
In order to secure an award under G.S. 97-30, the claimant has the burden of proving (1) that the injury resulted from accident arising out of and in the course of his employment; (2) that there resulted from that injury a loss of earning capacity (disability) ; and (3) that he must prove the extent of that disability. Hall v. Chevrolet Co., 263 N.C. 569, 139 S.E. 2d 857 (1965); Henry v. Leather Co., 231 N.C. 477, 57 S.E. 2d 760 (1950). Without such proof there is no authority upon which to make an award even though permanent physical injury may have been suffered. Branham v. Panel Co., 223 N.C. 233, 25 S.E. 2d 865 (1943).
In the instant case there is no evidence that plaintiff’s headaches resulted from the accidental injury to his left arm, except a statement by the plaintiff himself that prior to his injury he had never had habitual headaches. The Industrial Commission is the sole judge of the credibilty of the evidence. It may accept or reject the testimony of a witness, either in whole or in part. It is not required to accept even the uncontradicted testimony of a witness. Morgan v. Furniture Industries, Inc., 2 N.C. App. 126, 162 S.E. 2d 619 (1968).
Since there was no evidence that the plaintiff’s headaches did result from the injury, and since plaintiff did not take exception to the Commission’s finding of fact that the headaches were unrelated to the injury, there is no error in the Commission’s award.
No error.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.