State v. Thompson
State v. Thompson
Opinion of the Court
Prior to the trial court’s charge to the jury, defendant submitted a written request for a charge on the lesser included offense of misdemeanor assault. The court denied the request and instructed
The necessity for instructing the jury as to an included crime of lesser degree than that charged arises when and only when there is evidence from which the jury could find that such included crime of lesser degree was committed. The presence of such evidence is the determinative factor. Hence, there is no such necessity if the State’s evidence tends to show a completed robbery and there is no conflicting evidence relating to elements of the crime charged.
In the present case State’s evidence tended to show the taking of Earl’s money by defendant against Earl’s will by violent means. State’s evidence was not open to the interpretation that defendant committed only the lesser included offense of assault. Defendant specifically denied assaulting Earl, but admitted taking Earl’s money. On the basis of this evidence the court did not err by failing to instruct the jury on the lesser included offense of misdemeanor assault.
Defendant has also assigned as error the court’s summarization of his evidence in its charge to the jury that defendant was “flabbergasted” when June Bug began hitting Earl and that on the day following the alleged robbery Earl and his brothers “accosted” defendant but that “strangely nothing came of it.” Defendant contends that in so charging the jury the trial judge indicated to the jury that he gave little if any weight to defendant’s evidence. We find the statements objected to by defendant to be sufficiently supported by the evidence and not contrary to what defendant contended. Therefore such statements did not constitute an expression of opinion by the court. See State v. Joyner, 297 N.C. 349, 359-62, 255 S.E. 2d 390, 396-98 (1979). Defendant also contends that
In defendant’s trial we find
No error.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA v. MICHAEL J. THOMPSON
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published