Superior Court of North Carolina, 1803

Sheppard's Executors v. Cook's Executors

Sheppard's Executors v. Cook's Executors
Superior Court of North Carolina · Decided July 5, 1803 · Hall
3 N.C. 241

Counsel

Haywood, counsel for defendant , endeavored to continue the other case for want of a material witness; but HALL, J., said he would not receive any affidavit but the plaintiff himself; and said to Haywood: "You know that it is a rule you yourself have urged." I do not know whether he referred to Wheaton v. Cross , WILMINGTON, May Term, 1801. NOTE. — See, upon the first point, Quince v. Ross, ante , 180, and the cases referred to in the note thereto. And upon the second point, see contra, Wheaton v. Cross, ante , 154.

Sheppard's Executors v. Cook's Executors

Opinion of the Court

Hall, judge,

directed the jury, that from the 10th of March, 1773, to june, 1784, was not to be regarded in the computation of tinae---and that payment might be presumed in 15 or 16 years, with small circumstances to aid it.

They found for the defendant; and the plaintiff’s counsel moved for a new trial; and after argument, and time taken to consider,

Hall said, it is proper that the time for raising a presumption of payment against a bond, should be fixed and understood in the same way by all the courts. Some other judges hare considered that 20 years was the time s here there is neither 20, or even 18 years; so that the presumption has not attached, if *242 that opinion be correct. A.Iso, payment pleaded, means pay-rnent at the day ,- and if so, the evidence proved an admission of the debt long; since, and of course its existence since the time to which this plea refers. There must be a new trial.

Ilayvjcod endeavored to continue the other case for want of a materia', witness; but Hall said he would not receive any'affidavit but Cue plaintiff himself; and said to Haywood, “you know that it is a rule you yourself have urged.” I do not know whether he referred to T/heaton and Cross,- Wilmington,'May term, 1801.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.