Wilson v. Lineberger
Wilson v. Lineberger
Opinion of the Court
The covenant, the specific performance of which,, as á means of enforcing a lien upon the real estate described in the pleadings is demanded, embraces two distinct interests, one wholly personal to the contracting parties, the other the trust estate committed to the joint administration of the feme plaintiff and the defendant. The payment of the deferred purchase money for her share in the land sold, is to be secured by the conveyance of the estate of the debtor, thus charged, by a mort
Not only does this arrangement comprehend the retirement of the administratrix from the management, with a view to her being absolved from responsibility in the premises, but the mixing up of personal and trust matters in one and the same contract, may possibly lead to antagonism, a result not sanctioned in a Court of equity, and we may repeat what is said in N. C. R. R. Co. v. Wilson, 81 N. C., 223, “The law frowns upon any act on the part of a fiduciary, which places interest in antagonism to duty, or tends to that result.”
It is in this aspect of the case, we used the language repeated in the opinion now under review. “We are not prepared to uphold the contract in this feature, as one entitled to a specific performance, if its validity were now open to question.” Such
But aside from this, without needless repetition, we adhere to the reasoning pursued in the opinion, and now called in question, upon which the Court refused to decree a specific execution of the contract upon the first hearing of the appeal. Notwithstanding the able and exhaustive argument, and copious learning brought to bear upon the point, our convictions remain unchanged of the effect of the absence of averments necessary in sustaining the present claim, and which are not, because of their essential nature, waived by pleading over, as now contended.
We therefore adhere to our former ruling, and affirm the judgment.
Affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- J. H. WILSONs. v. C. J. LINEBERGER
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published