After a careful examination of tbe record, we fail to find any reversible error in tbe trial of tbe issues by either of tbe judges wbo tried them. The exception to the issues cannot be sustained. They present every contested matter presented by tbe pleadings. That Judge Carter did not render a final judgment, but permitted defendant to amend his answer and set up a counter-claim, is a matter of which the defendant cannot complain, since it cures any previous error in refusing to submit such issue. This counter-claim was fairly submitted to the jury at a subsequent term by Judge Justice and found against defendant. None of the assignments of error are directed to trial of the counter-claim.

Upon the whole record, we find

No error.