This case has been tried three times and is reported 171 N. C., 21; 173 N. C., 32.

We have examined the exceptions in the record and can find no substantial error that necessitates another trial. Three juries have an *686 swered tbe same issues in favor of tbe plaintiff, and we are not disposed to grant a new trial in suob cases unless tbe error assigned is of a character that manifestly requires it.

No error.