Supreme Court of North Carolina, 1928

McNeill v. . McGirt

McNeill v. . McGirt
Supreme Court of North Carolina · Decided March 28, 1928 · Stacy
142 S.E. 217; 195 N.C. 370; 1928 N.C. LEXIS 94 (South Eastern Reporter)

McNeill v. . McGirt

Opinion of the Court

Stacy, C. J.

The action of the trial court in withdrawing from the jury’s consideration the issues originally submitted on the second cause of action, must be held for error under the circumstances here disclosed. It appears from an inspection of the record that the contention of the defendants was submitted principally, if not wholly, upon these issues. Hence the court, in withdrawing them without further instruction, inadvertently took from the jury, certainly for all practical purposes, the defendants’ entire defense. This was error. Gaskins v. Mitchell, 194 N. C., 275, 139 S. E., 435.

The remaining exceptions are not considered, though it is observed that the decisions in Busbee v. Creech, 192 N. C., 499, 135 S. E., 326, and Sykes v. Everett, 167 N. C., 600, 83 S. E., 585, may become pertinent on another bearing. As to this, however, we express no opinion in advance of the evidence.

New trial.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.