Supreme Court of North Carolina, 1955

Swann v. Bigelow

Swann v. Bigelow
Supreme Court of North Carolina · Decided December 14, 1955 · Per Curiam
90 S.E.2d 396; 243 N.C. 285; 1955 N.C. LEXIS 574 (South Eastern Reporter, Second Series)

Swann v. Bigelow

Opinion

Per Curiam.

The presiding judge was in error in holding the answers to issues 2 and 3 as first returned by the jury were inconsistent. The court should have accepted the verdict and rendered judgment thereon, treating the answers to issue No. 3 as surplusage. To send the jury back for further consideration and to accept the verdict after the change was error. However, since the verdict as first returned was not accepted by the court there has been no proper verdict rendered in the case and for that reason the judgment entered is set aside. Butler v. Gantt, 220 N.C. 711, 18 S.E. 2d 119. The cause is remanded to the Superior Court of Caswell County for a

New trial.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.