Supreme Court of North Carolina, 1961

Rhyne v. Clark

Rhyne v. Clark
Supreme Court of North Carolina · Decided September 27, 1961 · Cukxam
255 N.C. 418; 121 S.E.2d 606; 1961 N.C. LEXIS 606

Rhyne v. Clark

Opinion of the Court

Per Cukxam.

“A demurrer lies only when the defect asserted as the ground of demurrer is apparent upon the face of the pleading attacked.” Construction Co. v. Electrical Workers Union, 246 N.C. 481, 488, 98 S.E. 2d 852; G.S. 1-127; G.S. 1-133. Facts alleged in defendants’ answer may not be considered in passing on the legal sufficiency of the complaint.

Here, the allegations of the complaint do not disclose “a defect of parties plaintiff or defendant.” G.S. 1-127(4). Nor do they disclose “that a necessary party ha(s) not been joined'as plaintiff or defendant.” Hence, the judgment sustaining defendants’ demurrer ore tenus and dismissing the action was erroneously entered and is reversed.

Reversed.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.