State v. Phipps
State v. Phipps
Opinion of the Court
This case brings to the Court a question as to the interpretation of N.C.G.S. § 14-148(a) which provides:
It is unlawful to willfully:
(2) Take away, disturb, vandalize, destroy or change the location of any stone, brick, iron or other material or fence enclosing a cemetery without authorization of law or consent of the surviving spouse or next of kin of the deceased thereby causing damage of less than one thousand dollars ($1,000); ....
The resolution of this case depends on the definition of a cemetery as used in the statute. If the bricks which were removed did not enclose a cemetery, the section of the statute does not apply. We hold that the site from which the bricks were removed was not a cemetery.
“Cemetery” is defined in Black’s Law Dictionary 223 (6th ed. 1990) as “[a] graveyard; burial ground. Place or area set apart for interment of the dead. ...” As we understand this definition, in order to be a cemetery, a plot must either contain the body of a deceased
State v. Wilson, 94 N.C. 1015 (1886), upon which the State relies, is not helpful to it. In that case, the defendant was convicted of removing a monument of stone erected for the purpose of designating the spot where a certain dead body was buried. In affirming the conviction we said, “[i]t is not questioned that the Legislature has the authority to protect burial grounds, and monuments to the dead, from desecration and outrage of every kind, by declaring such acts criminal . ...” Id. at 1020. We are not faced with the question of whether the General Assembly may prohibit the removal of a monument erected to honor the dead which is not a part of a cemetery. The General Assembly has not done so in the enactment of N.C.G.S. § 14-148(a)(2).
The State does not contend that the Hudson tract is a part of a larger cemetery.
For the reasons stated in this opinion, we affirm the decision of the Court of Appeals.
AFFIRMED.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA v. STACY RICHARD PHIPPS
- Status
- Published