Lacey v. Central National Bank
Opinion of the Court
As is clearly shown by the record the only exceptions taken by the plaintiff on the trial of the cause in the court below, was to the ruling of the court upon refusing to allow portions of the deposition of J. C. Mackoy to be read in evidence.
In answer to the sixth question, the witness states what was “understood” as the purpose and object of giving the note, and in answer to the ninth question he again states the “understanding” in respect to the giving of the note, and the seventh question was an inquiry as to whether or not this “ understanding was known to Lacey.” ITence, in answer to all these questions, the witness does not state what was said by himself or the cashier of the bank; he does not state the terms or conditions of any agreement or contract between the cashier and himself in regard to the purpose for which the note was given, or whether there was such contract — he does not state a single fact in regard to the matter; he simply and only speaks of his understanding of the matter, and this is no more than his mental conclusion, deduced from his interview with the cashier of the bank. In legal parlance, this understanding of the witness may be defined to be the faculty of the human mind, by which it receives or comprehends the ideas which others express and intend to communicate. And the expression of ideas of one person may and most usually will, in some material points, impress the minds of others with' different conclusions. Therefore, such deduction, however logical in order and truthful in substance the witness may consider the same to be, yet, I think it would be very unsafe to permit a jury to predicate a verdict on such testim ony. It is a principle well founded in reason, and the philosophy of moral evidence, that the witness testifying must state facts, and not deductions or con
The eighth question was an inquiry as to whether the witness mentioned to Lacey the names of any other persons who were to sign the note with him, and if so, who. The answer is that he mentioned the name of J. M. Mackoy, who did sign the note, and hence the question and answer were wholly i inmaterial; but at any rate, the answer could not be used as evidence against the bank, for the reason that the bank was not present at the time, and had no knowledge in regard to the matter.
The answer to the tenth question is irrelevant and was properly rejected, because it was a demand for security for an overdraft of the firm of Mackoy & Co., made long after the note was given, and when there was an overdraft of this firm to a large amount still due to the defendant in error.
But it is contended by the counsel for plaintiff in error, that the note was made to James W. "Watson, cashier, and not to the bank corporation, and, therefore, the action cannot be maintained by the defendant in error, without the indorsement of the note by James W. Watson. In.answer .to this argument it might be sufficient to state that the record shows no exception taken by the plaintiff in error to the introduction of the note in evidence on the trial. Hence, any objection which might have been made to the note was waived.
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.