Williams v. Bates
Williams v. Bates
Opinion of the Court
This action was commenced in the county court of Jefferson county to recover the sum of $85.00 and costs. The defendant demurred to the bill of particulars, the demurrer was sustained and the action dismissed. The district court affirmed the judgment of the county court.
This being a case where a justice -of the peace has cognizance neither the statute nor the practice in justice’s courts authorize a demurrer to a bill of particulars. This objection, however, was not urged in the brief of either attorney and will not be interposed by the court.
It is alleged in the bill of particulars “ that on or about the 18th day of April, 1880, the defendant purchased of the plaintiff certain real estate, and in part payment therefore sold to the plaintiff a promissory note for $82, given by one E. W. Davis, to B. S. Barker or bearer; that the defendant represented that said note was good and valuable and worth its face, and that Davis, the maker thereof, resided near Eairbury, Nebraska, and the defendant “knew of no reason why the note should not be promj>tly paid when due ”; that at the time of making these representations the defendant well knew that said note had been paid and the security released, and that said note was worthless for the reason that Davis, the maker thereof, had fully paid the same to the defendant. There is also an allegation that (he defendant had assumed the payment of the note, and had with funds received from Davis paid the same in full. It is alleged that Davis is not a resident of the state, and that said note has not been paid to the plaintiff.
Reversed and remanded.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.