Burcham v. Griffeth
Burcham v. Griffeth
Opinion of the Court
This action was brought by the plaintiff against the defendant to recover the sum of $500 with interest thereon for September 18, 1887.
On the trial of the cause in the court below the jury returned a verdict for the defendant, upon which judgment was rendered.
The testimony tends to show that on the 16th of September, 1887, the defendant sold to the plaintiff ninety-five head of fat steers at $4.30 per hundred pounds, with a shrinkage in weight of three per cent; that the steers were then on the defendant’s farm about six miles west of Raymond; that the steers were then weighed and the value thereof computed being the sum of $5,325.35. This sum was paid by the plaintiff to the defendant at Lincoln on the day succeeding the sale (September 17). “The sale seems to have been made on Friday and it was understood that the cattle were to be shipped to Omaha in a few days —possibly on the next day after the sale. An arrangement was made, however, as to feeding them until they were shipped. After conferring with the commission men in South Omaha, the plaintiff concluded to ha,ve the cattle on that market on Monday morning, the 19th inst.
The question presented is, Which of the parties shall sustain the loss ?
The clear weight of the testimony shows that the cattle were sold, weighed, paid for, and delivered on the 17th of September, 1887, and had any of the number been lost after that date the plaintiff would have been the party injured.
On the issue made by the pleadings and the proof, the question is one of. fact for the jury, and the verdict seems to be in conformity to the proof. Considerable stress is laid on th'e failure to instruct as to the proper measure of damages. There can be no error in this until it appears that the plaintiff is entitled to recover some damages. That the proof fails to show in this case. There is no error in the record, and the judgment is
Affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Henry Burcham v. Charles Griffeth
- Status
- Published