Powers v. House
Powers v. House
Opinion of the Court
The plaintiff in the suit below was Jacob E. House. The defendants were George R. Scougal, Martin P. Ohlman, William M. Powers, Miles T. Wooley, and E. M. Ziebach, of whom Powers only was served. The plaintiff House is a civil engineer, and resides in the city of Omaha. The defendants constituted a committee appointed at a meeting of the citizens of Yankton, Dakota, and resided in Yankton. This committee was appointed for the purpose of supervising and taking charge of a survey of a proposed line of railroad from Yankton to Sioux Falls, in the then territory of Dakota.
The petition alleges, in substance, the employment of the plaintiff by this committee at a salary of $200 per month and expenses; that the plaintiff commenced work about
The answer upon behalf of Mr. Powers, the only defendant upon whom service was had, sets up the following defenses:
“First — That the plaintiff House was hired by the committee, to be paid at the rate of $200 per month, the plaintiff agreeing to find and run a good practicable line for the proposed road, and also, in consideration of being allowed to be absent from the field of operations when not needed, he would at all other times be present for the carrying on of the work, and would devote such time, attention, and skill to the making of the survey as might be necessary and requisite; that the plaintiff entered upon the prosecution of his work September 26, 1887, and upon November 2, 1887, was notified by the committee that his services were no longer needed.”
The answer then sets up the law of Dakota relating to the limited obligation of a party acting as agent.
As a further defense and as a counter-claim it is alleged in answer that the plaintiff House was frequently, for days together, absent from the field of operations on the survey when his assistance and skill were needed for the proper carrying on of the work; that the plaintiff so negligently and carelessly did his work that it was of no value whatever; that the line projected by the plaintiff was never used, and that the amount expended in the survey, to-wit, over $800, was lost to the defendants, and that the entire work had to be done over at great expense to the defendants.
In reply the plaintiff denies that he was hired in the city of "Yankton, but insists that the contract was made in the city of Omaha by one J. H. Teller, representing the com
On the trial of the cause the jury returned a verdict in favor of House for the sum of $327, upon which judgment was rendered.
The testimony tends to show the following in regard to the contract between House and the defendants. The citizens of Yankton had for some time been desirous of building a railroad from the city of Yankton, Dakota, to the-city of Sioux Falls, Dakota, a distance of about seventy miles. "With this end in view, a public meeting of the citizens of Yankton was held, money was raised by subscription, and a committee comprising five of the representative citizens of that place was appointed. The duty of this committee was to provide for a survey of the proposed railroad and to disburse the funds collected at the meeting for carrying on the project. The country which it was proposed the new- railroad should traverse between the points spoken of was, in part, x’ough and hilly, and presented in places points of difficulty as to grade, and in general was of such a nature as to require the skill and experience of an expert civil engineer; that one of the principal inducements to the making of the px-oposed road lay in the fact that it was to be adopted and used by the St. Paul, Minneapolis & Manitoba Railroad Company. To-meet the requirements of the latter road it was necessary that the new road should have no grades exceeding thirty feet to the mile. For these reasons the services of an engineer skilled in the location of a 'railroad were absolutely necessary. At the request of the committee and in fact constituting a member of
Affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- William M. Powers v. Jacob E. House
- Status
- Published