Palmer v. Stiles
Palmer v. Stiles
Opinion of the Court
William A. Palmer sued John Stiles in the county court for an amount within the jurisdiction of a justice of the peace. The defendant appeared, and filed the following: “Comes now the defendant, and says that prior to the commencement of this suit defendant offered to pay plaintiff $4.50. And this defendant now offers to allow plaintiff to take judgment for ($4.50) four dollars and fifty cents.” The plaintiff filed an acceptance of the offer, con
The only question in this case is whether the court erred in its ruling on the question to retax the costs. Section 1004 of the code, which is relied on to sustain this ruling, is as follows: “If the defendant, at any time before trial, offer in writing to allow judgment to be taken against him for a specified sum, the plaintiff may immediately have a judgment therefor, with the costs then accrued. But if he do not accept such offer before the trial, and fail to recover in the action a sum equal to the offer, he cannot recover costs accrued after the offer, but costs must be adjudged against him. But the offer and failure to accept it cannot be given in evidence, to affect the recovery, otherwise than as to costs as above provided.” The object of this section is to encourage litigants to compromise their differences. It contemplates an offer made in terms that, when accepted as made, entitles the plaintiff to judgment for the amount specified, with the costs then accrued, without further litigation. It was unnec
It is therefore recommended that the order of the district court taxing the costs to the plaintiff be reversed and the cause remanded, with directions to tax the entire costs of the action to the defendant.
By the Court: For the reasons stated in the foregoing opinion, the order of the district court taxing the costs to the plaintiff is reversed1 and the cause remanded, with directions to tax the entire costs of the action to the defendant.
Reversed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- William A. Palmer v. John Stiles
- Cited By
- 2 cases
- Status
- Published