First National Bank of University Place v. Gates

Nebraska Supreme Court
First National Bank of University Place v. Gates, 104 Neb. 230 (Neb. 1920)
176 N.W. 726; 1920 Neb. LEXIS 130
Day, Letton, Morrissey

First National Bank of University Place v. Gates

Opinion of the Court

Morrissey, C. J.

The question before us is whether, under section 8189, Rev. St. 1913, a party appealing to the supreme court *231from a judgment in a law action, in order to supersede the judgment, must file a supersedeas bond within 20 days after the entry of the judgment, or-whether it is sufficient to file such bond within 20 days after the overruling of the motion for a new trial.

Section 8189,- Rev. St. 1913, provides that an appeal shall not operate as a supersedeas in any case, unless the appellant executes a proper bond “within twenty days next after the rendition of such judgment or decree, or the making of such final order.” A judgment or decree in an equity case may be treated as final, so as to give a right of appeal, immediately upon its rendition, but in a law action the character of finality which a judgment must possess in order to be reviewable in this court does not attach until the overruling of a motion for a new trial. If the time for filing a supersedeas bond begins to run from the day the judgment is entered, it might operate so as to require the execution of this instrument while the motion for a new trial was still pending, while the judgment was not yet subject to review by this court, and while it was still uncertain whether an appeal would be necessary. Such a situation was not intended by the legislature. The time does not begin to run until the motion for a new trial is overruled.

Affirmed.

Letton and Day, JJ., not sitting.

Reference

Full Case Name
First National Bank of University Place v. George M. Gates
Cited By
1 case
Status
Published