Supreme Court of New Hampshire, 1935

Schwotzer v. Sherwood

Schwotzer v. Sherwood
Supreme Court of New Hampshire · Decided June 4, 1935 · PER CURIAM.
179 A. 361; 87 N.H. 486; 1935 N.H. LEXIS 57

Counsel

Aloysius J. Connor (by brief and orally), for Schwotzer and Ahern., John D. Warren, for Urick., Lucier & Dowd (Mr. Dowd orally), for the defendant.

Schwotzer v. Sherwood

Opinion of the Court

Per Curiam.

There was abundant evidence of the defendant’s negligence. The mere fact that Urick, in the emergency, turned his car to the left did not preclude recovery. Gale v. Lisbon, 52 N. H. 174, 180, 181. See also Reed v. Company, 84 N. H. 156, 159. He had a right to a reasonable use of the road, and in turning to the left he was not attempting to pass the defendant’s car. Having rightfully done what he did, he was not hable merely because he helped to create a situation dangerous to others as well as himself.

Nor were the plaintiffs necessarily at fault for failing to jump from the car. The car was stalled and Urick was trying his best to get it *488 started. It was a two-door sedan, and the other plaintiffs were on the rear seat. What due care required under the circumstances was essentially a question of fact. Folsom v. Railroad, 68 N. H. 454, 460.

This conclusion makes it unnecessary to consider the defendant’s contention that the plaintiffs cannot recover under the doctrine of the last clear chance. No exception to the submission of that issue was taken.

Judgments on the verdicts.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.