In re the Appeal from the Decree of the Orphans Court of the County of Passaic
Opinion of the Court
This is an appeal from an order of the orphans court, admitting a will to probate after a contest on the ground that the deceased was of unsound mind.
The testatrix, Jane Lucas, died in December, 1934, having made the will in question in 1931. Her estate consisted almost exclusively of a savings account in the Paterson Savings Institution amounting to approximately $23,000. Just prior to the execution of the will, she transferred some smaller
Testatrix was very aged at the time of the making of the will and was admittedly eccentric. Her son was sixty years of age and was unmarried, although there was evidence tending to show that the testatrix had a delusion to the effect that her son was secretly married and had a child.
Voluminous testimony was taken in the court below and that court had filed an opinion which fully discussed the evidence submitted. The court found on the testimony before it that the evidence was insufficient to show a degree of mental incapacity sufficient to invalidate the will. As pointed out in the opinion, the requisite capacity to make a will is very low. A recent decision reaffirming the long established law in this state on this matter is In re Triebe, 114. N. J. Eq. 227. The court says:
“The right of testamentary disposition may be exercised by a person of very moderate mental capacity. If he is capable of recollecting of what his property consists and who, either in consequence of ties of blood or friendship should be the objects of his bounty, and has a mind sufficiently sound to enable him to know and to understand what disposition he wants to make of his property after his death, he is competent to make a valid will.”
It appears from the opinion that the court gave full credence to the testimony of witnesses who participated in the execution of the will and who testified that the will was
It was the duty of the court below to weigh the testimony and to determine the credence and weight to be given thereto.
The court below having found that testatrix had sufficient mentality to make the will in question and there having been nothing adduced on this appeal to show that the court was not justified in its decision, the order appealed from will be affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.