Fidelity Union Trust Co. v. Ferguson
Fidelity Union Trust Co. v. Ferguson
Opinion of the Court
This is a suit to recover a tax of $2,738.66 paid May 23, 1923. The sole question is whether a tax of $45,644.03 levied by Essex county, N. J., for the year 1917, is a deductible item under the federal Corporation Tax Law (U. S. C. S. 1913, § 6301 [36 Stat. 112]). The plaintiff elected that taxes be levied as provided for by section 8 of the New Jersey Bank Stock Tax Act of 1914 (P. L. 1914, p. 141), as follows (the italics are mine):
“If any bank, banking association or trust company shall, by resolution of its board of directors filed as hereinafter provided, request the county board of taxation to assess to and in the name of the bank, banking association or trust company the entire taxable value of all the shares of stock; therein, instead of assessing the same to and in the name of the individual shareholders
Apparently the act permits a New Jersey bank to choose whether the tax shall be levied upon the stockholders or upon the bank. If the latter course is adopted, and it was here, the obligation is that of the bank and not that of the shareholders. If the tax were levied upon and paid by the stockholders, they could have deducted the same. But it was not. It was levied upon and paid by the bank. Not to permit it to deduct is to impose an income tax upon taxes paid — a curious anomaly.
Let judgment accordingly be entered.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- FIDELITY UNION TRUST CO. v. FERGUSON
- Status
- Published