District Court, D. New Jersey, 2021

JAMES v. PATEL

JAMES v. PATEL
District Court, D. New Jersey · Decided June 10, 2021 · No. 2:19-cv-08757
JAMES v. PATEL

Trial Court Opinion

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY

KARINA E. JAMES,

Civ. No. 19- 08757 (KM)(JBC)

Plaintiff,

ORDER v.

DR. SUNIL PATEL, NIMISH PATEL,

AMIT VAJAWALA, and ISELIN ADULT

MEDICAL DAY CARE,

Defendants.

KEVIN MCNULTY, U.S.D.J.:

This matter comes before the Court on the motion (DE 25) of Plaintiff Karina E. James for an amended default judgment.

IT APPEARING that James, proceeding pro se, initiated this action against Dr. Sunil Patel, Nimish Patel, Amit Vajawala, and Iselin Adult Medical Day Care, asserting federal employment discrimination claims (DE 1); and IT FURTHER APPEARING that on October 19, 2020, the Court, upon James’s motion, entered an order of default judgment totaling $110,000 (DE 11, 17, 18); and

IT FURTHER APPEARING that on March 17, 2021, James moved for an amended default judgment ordering that defendants Dr. Sunil Patel, Nimish Patel, and Amit Vajawala each pay James $110,000, totaling $330,000 (DE 25); and

IT FURTHER APPEARING that a district court, on a motion for default judgment, need not accept a plaintiff’s allegations of damages, rather a plaintiff must prove damages, United States v. $240,431 in U.S. Currency, Civ. No. 19- 12834, 2020 WL 1182909, at *3 (D.N.J. Mar. 11, 2020); and IT FURTHER APPEARING that the damages sought in the complaint and motion for default judgment only totaled $110,000 (DE 1 at 8; DE 11 at 1; DE at 1), so the pleadings and motion do not provide notice that $330,000 is sought; and

IT FURTHER APPEARING that the damages sought, stemming from James’ employment with Defendants, are not of a nature that they would be owed duplicatively by each defendant (see DE 1 at 8);

IT IS THEREFORE this 10th day of June, 2021,

ORDERED that Plaintiff’s motion for an amended default judgment (DE 25) is DENIED. The clerk shall close the file.

/s/ Kevin Mcnulty ____________________________________ Kevin McNulty

United States District Judge

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.