Woolley v. Sergeant
Woolley v. Sergeant
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
This case, which originated in the court for small causes, went into the Common Pleas by appeal, and into this Court by certiorari, presents a question touching the legal responsibilities of a guarantee under the following circumstances. One Miller drew a request upon Sergeant, to credit 30 dollars on book account to Woolley; he Miller promising to pay the money at a certain day; and Woolley himself giving a guaranty of this promise on the back of the instrument. Sergeant never demanded payment of Miller, though the latter lived in good credit several months after the money became payable, before he removed out of the place, leaving it wholly unpaid and lost. The question is, on which party 'the law imposes this loss ?
In cases of guaranty and suretyship, the law regulates the responsibility of parties by a general rule; but with its usual sagacity, it provides that general rule with every wise and necessary exception; so that the general rules of law appear open and plain, like common highways, while the exceptions resemble drift ways,' and lanes, by being a
But an inquiry yet remains to be made touching the exception to the general rule; and whether this guaranty may not come under such exception. The mercantile transactions of the country, which are mostly done on short periods of credit, and constitute a great portion of the common mass of business, generally employ in their traffic two kinds of paper, under the names of bills of exchange and negotiable notes; and the law, out of favor to commerce, has made for these mercantile instruments, an exception to the general rule, by making the responsibility of parties thereto, conform to the custom of merchants. Under this exception, the parties find their dutes very different from those under the general rule, and nearly inverted; for here the surety has nothing to do; while the most punctual diligence is exacted from the creditor ; he must make a demand of the debt as soon as it becomes due, and give immediate notice of non payment to the surety; a neglect of either of which duties will absolve the surety in case of a loss. But this exception, founded on the law merchant extends to commercial instruments only, and was never applied to paper
The present guaranty is given upon an ixxstrumexxt in xxo wise commercial, in no respect negotiable, nor capable of circulation in the general market; and an example of placing such instruments under the regulations px-ovided for commercial paper only, beside perverting the law merchant to a foreign use, and confounding' the general rule axxd exception together, would spread a net-work of forms over the non-commercial and plaixx dealings of the country, and catch and entangle the property of those who are not merchants nor familiar with the numerous rules that govern
Judgment affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- John Woolley v. David Sergeant
- Status
- Published