Keen v. Den ex dem. Saxton

Supreme Court of New Jersey
Keen v. Den ex dem. Saxton, 17 N.J.L. 313 (N.J. 1839)
Hornblower

Keen v. Den ex dem. Saxton

Opinion of the Court

Hornblower, C. J.

It seems, from what has been said at the bar, that the declaration describes the premises in question as lying in the township of Stillwater; and that whether they lie in Stillwater, or in Newton, depends upon the true location of the line between East and West Jersey, which is the matter really in dispute between the parties. Hence the landlord declined entering into a consent rule admitting possession of, and agreeing to defend for lands lying in Stillwater, as he claims none in that township, but insists that the lands in possession of his tenant, and for which this action is brought lie within the township of Newton. The plaintiff on the other hand, contends that the defendant ought either to have signed the usual consent rules, or to have got the order of this court for a special consent rule adapted to the peculiarities of the case. In this he is probably correct; but it appears that a negotiation upon the subject was opened between the parties, which not resulting in any arrangement satisfactory to the plaintiff, he entered up judgment against the casual ejector, and by a writ of Hob. fac. possessionem, turned the defendant out of possession. It is somewhat difficult to say, which party has been most in default; but inasmuch, as it appears that there is a defence on the merits, and that no delay was *314intended, let the judgment be set aside and a writ of restitution be issued and executed at the expense of the defendant; and the costs of the judgment and writ of possession and of this motion, abide the event of the suit.

In the mean time, let the consent rule be eptcred into, without naming the township in which the lands lie; and the plaintiff have leave to amend his declaration by striking out the name of the township, and making it a declaration for land in the county of Sussex.

Ford, White, Dayton, and Neyids, Justices, concurred.

Motion granted without costs, and consent rule modified.

Reference

Full Case Name
KEEN tenant, &c. adsm. DEN ex dem. SAXTON
Status
Published