Kaighn v. Fuller

The decree of the Chancellor was affirmed by the following vote (the court being equally divided):

For affirmance—Judges Brown, Combs, Vredenburgh, Whelpley, Wood—5.

For reversal—Judges Cornelison, Haines, Ogden, Fort, Swain—5.

In this case Chief Justice Whelpley read an opinion for affirmance, and Judge Ogden read an opinion for a reversal.