Mayor of Hoboken v. Kamena
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- US Fidelity & Guaranty Co. v. Davis (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. 1954)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
This action is brought against Kamena and his sureties on an official bond given to the plaintiff, conditioned that the defendant, Kamena, would truly and faithfully perform all the duties enjoined on him as treasurer of the city of Hoboken, and would safely and securely keep the moneys of the said city entrusted to him as treasurer as aforesaid. This bond bears date the fourteenth day of June, 1877, and was approved and accepted on the fifth day of July then next folloAving.
Kamena Avas first elected treasurer of Hoboken in May, 1872, and annually thereafter re-elected to and including the year 1877. At his last election, failing to enter into the required bond, the office was on the twenty-ninth of May, 1877, declared vacant, and on the same day Kamena Avas appointed to fill the vacancy for the ensuing year. In pursuance of this
It is for breach of the conditions of this bond that this -action has been brought.
The first issue raised by the pleadings is whether, prior to the giving of the bond, Kamena had been, to the knowledge •of the city, guilty of embezzlement of the public moneys entrusted to his charge, and of which his sureties were ignorant and not informed by the city.
The only finding on this point by the special verdict on which the case is presented at bar is, that by special city ordinance the treasurer was required forthwith to deposit all moneys which he might from time to time receive, in such one ■or more banks as the council might direct, and if no such direction was given, then in such bank as he should select, and that the council having under this ordinance directed the treasurer to deposit the city funds received by him in the First National Bank of Hoboken, he failed to comply with such direction. This fact, however, does not show any fraudulent dealing by the treasurer with respect to or misappropriation or embezzlement by him of the city funds. A mere failure to place the moneys of the city in a particular •depository designated by council, is not proof that such moneys were misappropriated, wasted or embezzled, and does not show that they were not appropriated to the use and benefit of the city. The treasurer’s conduct in not depositing the city funds in the bank designated by council may have been irregular, but from this fact alone it cannot legally be inferred that it was fraudulent. The bond cannot be avoided on the ground suggested.
We come, then, to the question whether from the facts found in the special .verdict it is shown that there was any misappropriation or embezzlement of the city funds by the treasurer between the fifth of July, when the bond was accepted, and the twenty-second of November next following, when he resigned his office. It is conceded that he was a ■defaulter in the previous year or years of his official existence.
It is in the next place contended that the payment of $10,000 by the treasurer to the county collector in September, 1877, for or on account of the county tax of 1876, was a misappropriation of funds in hand at the time of such payment. The facts in respect to this charge as found are, that in January, 1877, the treasurer transmitted by mail to
It is further contended that the treasurer misappropriated $3100, in that he drew from the city treasury this amount for his own personal use and benefit. But as the verdict finds that this was done simply to reimburse himself for so much that he had advanced from his own private funds for the use and benefit of the city when away from his office, and the transaction, being free of all fraud in fact, did not, I think, amount to misappropriation or embezzlement. By it the city lost nothing.
The plaintiff is entitled to judgment in its favor, for nominal damages only, on the issue that the treasurer did not deposit in the bank designated by council the funds of the city entrusted to his keeping.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.