Clifford v. Hudson County Oyer & Terminer
Clifford v. Hudson County Oyer & Terminer
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
Edward Clifford was indicted for murder and tried before the Hudson Oyer and Terminer, where he was found guilty of murder of the first degree and sentenced to be hung. This judgment was affirmed in this court and in the Court of Errors and Appeals upon successive writs of. error. Application is now made for a mandamus to compel the Court of Oyer and Terminer to amend its record by inserting therein that the indictment was tried by a strueh jury and not by a petit jury—that is, that the jury was selected in the method prescribed by the eighteenth section of the Jury act, and not by that prescribed in the thirteenth and following sections.
This application loses sight of the essential difference between the record of a court and the history of the trial of a cause therein. The record of a court contains only those things that are essential to the validity of the proceeding, such as the nature of the issue, the presence of a judge, and in respect to the jury, that it was of the proper number of proper men, properly qualified and returned by the proper
From this brief exposition it follows that the fact that the jury that tried this indictment was selected from the body •of the county by the statutory method of striking a jury cannot be made a part of the record of the Court of Oyer and Terminer.
This disposes of the application for a mandamus, which is, for this reason, denied.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- EDWARD CLIFFORD v. HUDSON COUNTY OYER AND TERMINER
- Cited By
- 3 cases
- Status
- Published