Miller v. Greenwalt
Miller v. Greenwalt
Opinion of the Court
The challenged statute is, we think, constitutional. The power of creating municipal corporations is inherent and. exclusive in the legislative department of the government. In re Ridgefield Park, 25 Vroom 288. Nothing in the amendment of 1875, limiting to general laws the power of regulating internal affairs of towns and counties, curtails the power of creation. This is conceded in the decisions interpreting the amendment, although the grounds for the concessions have not been uniformly taken. It was the opinion of Chief Justice Beasley that the legislature may resort to a local or special law in any case where a legitimate object cannot be attained by a general law. Van Riper v. Parsons, 11 Vroom 1. At the same term Mr. Justice Van Syckel suggested that creation, or change of lines, of political divisions did not regulate internal affairs. Pell v. Newark, 11 Id. 71. The Chief Justice would not accept this view, and in a later case reiterated the opinion expressed in Van Riper v. Parsons, applying the doctrine, by way of. illustration, as justifying legislative power to create a change in the lines of municipalities by local and special laws. Dempsey v. Newark, 24 Id. 4. Other judges sitting in that cause were unwilling to unite in declaring the postulate of the Chief Justice, it not being necessary to the decision to do so. Any change in existing political divisions certainly affects, though it may be said not to regulate, the internal affairs of the divisions concerned, and a change in towns may affect the internal affairs of counties. Nevertheless, the plain constitutional power to make such changes cannot be destroyed by implication. It has not been expressly destroyed, and the amendment must be so construed as to preserve it. I think a reasonable construction js that new divisions may be created and existing lines may be changed by local and special laws at the legislative will, but that any regulation of the internal affairs of the changed divisions must be accomplished by some valid law—that is, a general or special law enacted prior to the amendment or a general law enacted since the
Let the rule to show cause be made absolute and a peremptory mandamus be issued as prayed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.