Snyder v. J. S. Rogers Co.
Snyder v. J. S. Rogers Co.
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
The writ of error brings up a judgment of nonsuit. The plaintiff was a painter in the employ of the defendant compunja, which was engaged in painting the coiling and side walls- of a room within a building. This room occupied in height two stories of other parts of the- building. In order' to paint the ceiling it was necessary to erect a scaffolding for the painter to stand upon. ' The scaffolding was io be made of a ladder, below and nearly parallel with the ceiling, and a board or plank laid on the rungs between
It seems, from the'evidence, that it was a customary thing to use ladders in this way, and that the plaintiff had assisted in so using them in the construction of the scaffolding. If it was a dangerous mode of using such ladders, the plaintiff was as familiar with that danger as the master. He was a painter of many years’ experience, accustomed to use ladders in his business, and must be considered to have had knowledge whether or not an ordinary ladder could be safely used in. the manner in which the ladder .was used in this case. If the ladder broke because of any incompleteness of the scaffold, the plank on it being lacking whereby the weight would be distributed, then it was the plaintiff’s own negligence in attempting to use the scaffold before it was completed, he being engaged in building- it.
This ladder was one of several similar to it provided by the master to be used in the business, and was selected and brought to the job by the foreman. It consisted of two side pieces, with rungs in, holes in the side pieces. It had been painted. There is nothing to indicate that the ladder was defective, rotten or unsafe. To all outward appearance it was strong and sufficient for the purpose to which it was put; when it broke one side broke square off, and the wood was, at .the point of fracture, “brittle, like chalk.” It does not appear that this was a structural defect, or that it was a defect that
We are unable to find any negligence or failure of duty of the defendant subjecting it to liability to damages.
The judgment of nonsuit will be affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.