Keuffel v. Mayor of Hoboken
Keuffel v. Mayor of Hoboken
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
This writ brings up a resolution of the common council of Hoboken, by which the corporation attorney of that city is directed to have a deed executed conveying to the trustees of the free public library of the city of Hoboken the title to the free public library property mentioned in a communication from the corporation attorney to the common council. i
The resolution is attacked upon the ground that the common council had no power to transfer the title to this property to the board of trustees of the free public librar}', inasinuch as the city itself was the appropriate custodian of the title.
On January 7th, 1896, Mrs. M. R. Stevens made a deed of a site of land to the mayor and common council of Hoboken, for which site she paid $17,719.40; the difference between this sum and the $26,000, the amount of her donation, namely, $8,280.60, was paid to the board of trustees of the free public library. The building upon the site was erected at a cost of $60,280.60, and the difference between this sum and the $8,280.60 was raised by the issue of city bonds. These bonds seem to have been issued upon the certificate of the board of trustees of the amount necessary for the purpose of building the structure, under the provisions of the supplement to the act of 1884 (Gen. Stat., p. 1950), which supplement was passed March 21st,' 1895. Gen. Stat., p.' 1953. This supplement provides that the title of real estate purchased under its provisions shall be taken in the name of the city, and the use and control of the same shall be in the board of trustees of the free public library so long as it shall be used for library purposes.
The policy of the act is to have the legal title in the municipality, while its use, so long as the purpose for which it is intended exists, shall be confided to the board of trustees.
We conclude that the resolution was a municipal act, in contravention of the statute, and should be annulled.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- WILLIAM KEUFFEL, PROSECUTORS v. MAYOR AND COMMON COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HOBOKEN
- Status
- Published