Home Circle Realty Corp. v. Giesenhaus
Home Circle Realty Corp. v. Giesenhaus
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
This writ of certiorari brings up a warrant of removal'in a summary proceeding brought by a landlord to dispossess a tenant for non-payment of rent.
The only question is whether the District Court had jurisdiction. The jurisdictional affidavit of the landlord sets out that part of the rent that remains unpaid is $12.60, which is one-half of the difference between the tax paid on the property in 1909 and the tax levied on the property in 1912! This item, as a part of the rent to be paid by the tenant, is thus set forth in the affidavit, “and also one-half the taxes levied upon the said premises by the city of Jersey City in excess of the taxes paid by the said plaintiff for the said premises for the year 1909; that the taxes for the said premises for year 1909 was the sum of $146.41, and that the taxes for the year 1912 are $171.60; said taxes respectively are payable to the city of Jersey City in advance.”
This description of a sum that is to be ascertained from the given data is entirely too uncertain to constitute rent; it is
Inasmuch as rent must be a sum certain or one that is capable of being reduced to certainty the landlord’s affidavit with respect to the controverted item failed to confer jurisdiction in a summary proceeding to dispossess for non-payment of rent.
The judgment of the Second District Court of the city of Jersey City is reversed and the proceeding dismissed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- HOME CIRCLE REALTY CORPORATION v. FRED WILLIAM GIESENHAUS, PROSECUTOR
- Status
- Published