Von Novelly v. Carpenter
Von Novelly v. Carpenter
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
The present action was brought to recover damages for breach of a contract. The complaint contains four counts. The defendants, contending that the second, third and fourth counts of the complaint to be bad, moved before the Circuit Court to strike them out. That court, conceiving that certain matters involved in the determination of the motion presented questions of doubt and difficulty, certified them to this court for its advisory opinion thereon.
The Circuit Court judge has stated in the record sent to us that the questions were certified pursuant to section 252 of the Practice act (Comp, Stat., p. 4128), which provides that “Any justice of the Supreme Court or judge of the Circuit Court, to whom application may be made for any rule or order by virtue of this act, may refer the same to the Supreme Court and make such order for the taking of testimony and for stay of proceedings as may be equitable.” This section, however, does not contemplate the rendition of advice by the Supreme Court to a judge of the Circuit Court for his guidance in acting upon such application; but is intended to transfer such matters as come within its purview to the Supreme Court for its consideration and determination, and consequently affords no basis for the procedure adopted by the Circuit Court in the present case.
The certified ease will he dismissed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.